In fact, I've come to think that, even if maudlin, they are the whole point of the war story they introduce and conclude. How could such a formidable filmmaker have botched the beginning and the end of his film?īut now, looking back as the 70th anniversary of D-Day approaches, I've begun to doubt that the opening and the closing of Saving Private Ryan are missteps. The opening and the closing of any work should be the two moments of greatest emphasis (as Spielberg's English-teacher hero, Captain John Miller, would no doubt have taught his high-school students back home in Addley, Pennsylvania). Lane did make quite clear that he had no patience for Spielberg's "sappy epilogue.") In nearly three hours, apart from the letter by Lincoln that General Marshall reads and the one that he himself writes to Ryan's mother, "Saving Private Ryan" offers not a single word about love of country. Anthony Lane, for example, writing in The New Yorker, described the first half-hour of the film as "the most telling battle scenes ever made" without bothering to note that one must first wade through five minutes of schmaltz to get to Omaha Beach. Janet Maslin conceded that these scenes are among the film's "few false notes." Others derided this opening and closing as "maudlin," "completely unnecessary," and "a burst of schmaltzy ritual." In fact, most writers simply ignored the prologue. Nearly every commentator criticized this prologue and epilogue. But Spielberg wraps not only the war in the flag but also the cloyingly sentimental frame story of an elderly veteran, followed by his wife, son, and grandchildren, on his pilgrimage to the vast cemetery overlooking the Normandy beachhead, now marked by row after row of simple Christian and Jewish headstones. Can we understand the flag as anything but an announcement of the subject of his epic: patriotism? The fluttering flag, denatured of its color and perhaps of its vitality, is the image with which the film begins and ends.
![war of beach critic war of beach critic](http://filmcritic.co/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/Copy-of-blue-2000x1200.jpg)
![war of beach critic war of beach critic](https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-TGeWDbdftNM/TebafIJaRoI/AAAAAAAAG9g/p8vvuDnJ_CA/s1600/beach6.jpg)
The first and last thing we see pulsing across the entire screen is a faded, translucent American flag.
#WAR OF BEACH CRITIC MOVIE#
Spielberg actually opens and closes the film twice, employing two pairs of images to bracket the war movie everyone praised. Like everyone else, I wondered at the courage or desperation or whatever it was that drove American soldiers across a French beach, codenamed Omaha, under the withering spray of German machine-gun rounds from hilltop fortifications and the flesh-shredding explosions of 105mm howitzer shells lobbed by inland artillery.Īnd like everyone else, I had to agree that it was brilliant filmmaking-except for the beginning and the end. Like everyone else in the theater, I spent most of three hours wincing involuntarily in my seat, shocked by the unrelenting mayhem of a daylight amphibious assault across a barren killing field, sickened by the sudden hash that light artillery can make of human bodies, groaning at the grotesque wounds and the grisly mutilations of whimpering casualties, and-in the end-twitching at even the slightest clatter of mechanized warfare.
#WAR OF BEACH CRITIC FULL#
But as my wife and I filed out of the theater, I wondered what they were applauding, exactly, this darkened room full of veterans and their spouses.
![war of beach critic war of beach critic](https://www.miamiartzine.com/atimo_s/articles_images/2019/12/FFCC_slideshow_1577127943.jpg)
Moved to tears by the powerful film, the audience gave it an ovation as the final credits rolled. Along with 6.5 million other Americans, I saw Saving Private Ryan its opening weekend back in 1998, joining a mostly elderly crowd of the "Greatest" generation at a suburban multiplex. The New York Times even devoted a respectful editorial to "Spielberg's War."Īnd I knew that almost everybody else agreed with them. Historian Stephen Ambrose, author of D-Day and Citizen Soldiers, thought it "the finest World War II movie ever made." The Secretary of the Army presented the filmmaker with the military's highest civilian decoration, the Distinguished Civilian Service Award. The most serious students of the Second World War shared the enthusiasm for the film.